Google Maps rankings in 2018 operated under a specific algorithm that prioritized different factors than desktop search results, and understanding these distinctions was critical for agencies serving local clients. The "near Los Angeles" phenomenon refers to how Google weighted relevance, distance, and prominence differently depending on whether a user searched for a service with explicit geographic intent versus browsing maps directly. In 2018, Google's local pack (the three business listings shown at the top of map results) was heavily influenced by NAP consistency—name, address, and phone number appearing identically across the web—citation quality from authoritative local directories, review count and recency, and the actual geographic distance between the searcher and the business. What made this particularly relevant for agencies was that ranking factors shifted based on search type; a user searching "plumber near Los Angeles" triggered different ranking signals than someone searching just "plumber" on Google Maps. Agencies that recognized this distinction could tailor optimization strategies rather than applying one-size-fits-all tactics.
For agencies, this mattered because local services were becoming increasingly competitive, and clients were frustrated when they appeared in search results but not in the coveted local pack. A 2018 study showed that nearly 80 percent of local searches resulted in a purchase within 24 hours, meaning rankings directly influenced revenue. Agencies that understood map ranking factors could justify their fees and deliver measurable results. Clients in Los Angeles—a massive, geographically dispersed market with intense service competition—were willing to pay for expertise that could get them into that top three position. This also meant agencies could differentiate themselves; many competitors were still treating maps as secondary to organic search, creating an opportunity for knowledgeable firms to capture market share by specializing in local pack optimization.
Practically, agencies should have prioritized citation building from industry-specific directories and local sources over generic citation sites. A dental practice ranking in Los Angeles benefited far more from listings in dental-specific directories than from appearing in generic "business directories." Agencies needed to audit client websites for review schema implementation and ensure that Google Business Profile information was not just accurate but perfectly formatted—inconsistent address formatting (using "St." in one place and "Street" in another) actually hurt rankings. Photo optimization within the Google Business Profile was underutilized in 2018, but agencies that systematized client photo uploads saw ranking improvements. Building a review generation system that encouraged recent reviews was essential, since recency weighted heavily; a business with ten reviews from the last month outranked one with 500 reviews from years past. For web designers working with agencies, this meant building websites with clear contact information, service area pages targeting specific Los Angeles neighborhoods, and technical implementation of local schema markup.
Need programmatic SEO content like this deployed across hundreds of pages for your clients? That's exactly what we build.
Get a free sample →