Google Maps ranking in 2018 was heavily dominated by relevance, distance, and prominence—the three core factors Google used to determine local pack positions. To improve your visibility, you needed to start with your Google My Business profile, which was absolutely foundational. Many agencies weren't optimizing this thoroughly enough. You had to ensure your business name, address, and phone number (NAP) matched exactly across Google My Business, your website, and local directories like Yelp, Yellow Pages, and industry-specific listings. Any inconsistency tanked your rankings. Your GMB category selection mattered enormously—choosing the most specific, accurate categories rather than broad ones gave you better relevance signals. You also needed to actively manage your GMB profile by posting updates regularly, responding to all reviews quickly, and adding photos consistently. Google was clearly rewarding engagement signals on the GMB platform itself.

Citation building remained critical in 2018, but the quality-over-quantity approach was already becoming evident. Getting your business listed in authoritative, relevant directories carried far more weight than being in dozens of low-quality ones. Local directories specific to your industry performed better than generic citation sites. You needed to target the platforms your customers actually used—if you were a plumber in Denver, being in local Denver business directories and construction-related sites mattered more than random citation aggregators.

On-page SEO still influenced local rankings significantly. Your website's title tags, meta descriptions, headers, and content needed to include your city and service keywords naturally. If you were ranking for "dentist in Chicago," that phrase needed to appear authentically in your site's content and structure. Local link building was another piece—getting links from local news sites, community organizations, and other relevant local businesses helped. Review generation was becoming increasingly important by 2018. Google was clearly giving ranking boosts to businesses with higher review volumes and better average ratings. Agencies needed to implement systems to encourage happy customers to leave Google reviews. The combination of a well-optimized GMB profile, consistent NAP citations, relevant on-page content, and a steady stream of positive reviews created the foundation for strong Google Maps rankings in 2018.

Need programmatic SEO content like this deployed across hundreds of pages for your clients? That's exactly what we build.

Get a free sample →