Google Maps ranking in 2016 depended heavily on local SEO signals that are still relevant today, though the algorithm has evolved. The primary factors Google weighted were business relevance to the search query, distance from the searcher, and prominence of your business across the web. To rank higher, you needed to ensure your Google My Business listing was completely filled out with accurate information—business name, address, phone number, hours, and categories. The categories you selected mattered significantly because Google used them to match your business with relevant searches. Many agencies made the mistake of choosing vague categories when being specific actually helped rankings. You also needed to include high-quality photos directly in your GMB listing, as businesses with regular photo updates ranked better than those without.
Off-Google-Maps signals were equally important for local pack visibility in 2016. The quantity and quality of online reviews, particularly on Google itself, heavily influenced your map rankings. Businesses needed consistent citation data across directories like Yelp, Yellow Pages, and industry-specific listings—meaning your NAP (name, address, phone) needed to match perfectly everywhere it appeared. You should have focused your citation efforts on high-authority local directories relevant to your industry rather than spreading thin across hundreds of low-quality sites. Local backlinks and mentions of your business on relevant local websites also carried weight, so partnerships with local organizations, sponsorships, and local press coverage genuinely helped rankings.
On-site SEO still mattered for map visibility in 2016, contrary to what some believed. Your website needed location-specific content that targeted local keywords naturally. If you were an agency building websites for clients, you'd recommend creating location pages for service areas, optimizing title tags and meta descriptions for local intent, and ensuring the website's footer contained the business address. Google also factored in how well your website content matched the business category and service descriptions you listed in GMB. The ranking algorithm also considered user behavior signals like click-through rates from the map to your website and direct calls from the map listing, so clear calls-to-action and mobile optimization were practical necessities. Agencies that optimized these elements comprehensively—GMB completeness, review generation, consistent citations, and local website optimization—consistently achieved better local pack positions than competitors relying on just one or two factors.
Need programmatic SEO content like this deployed across hundreds of pages for your clients? That's exactly what we build.
Get a free sample →